
E-collars are extremely useful for training your pets either for sport or any professional activity. Different training kits come with different features. Therefore it is best to know the diverse use and features of different products before you can make an informed purchase.
Through this article you can get a clear understanding of the two products – Dogtra ARC and 1900 E-collar as we will give you a detailed analysis. We will be comparing the key features of the two products and also understand the pros and cons of both the items.
So first let’s list down the features of the products and understand them in detail.
Dogtra ARC
The Dogtra ARC is meant mainly for small to medium sized dogs. They can weigh somewhere around 15 pounds and have comparatively softer nature and low temper. The collar is lighter in weight and medium sized best suited for average sized dogs.
Key Features
Range – ¾ Mile
Receiver – Ergonomic Slim Designed Receiver
Output Type – Medium Output
Electric Correction Type– Nick/Constant Correction
Vibration Correction Type – Pager Vibration
Correction Levels – 127 Correction Levels/ Rheostat Dial/ LCD Screen
Expandability – Expandable to two dogs
Resistance – Fully Waterproof
1900 E-Collar
The Dogtra 1900 is built for larger dogs with high temperament. The dogs can weigh above 20 pounds and have a sturdier look. The power system is high which can control rugged activities by more active and stubborn pets.
Key Features
Range – ¾ Mile
Receiver – Ergonomic Slim Receiver
Output Type – High Output
Electric Correction Type– Nick/Constant Correction
Vibration Correction Type – HPP Vibration
Correction Levels – 127 Correction Levels/ Rheostat Dial/ LCD Screen
Expandability – Only for 1 dog
Controller – Handsfree Remote Controller
Resistance – IPX9K waterproof
Batteries – 2-Hour Rapid Charge Lithium Polymer Batteries
Specification Comparison
Dogtra ARC vs. 1900 E-Collar – Design
The Dogtra ARC is sleek and has a trendy outlook built specifically for small to medium size dogs. Also the design is fully water-resistant so you can train your dogs in water activities as well. The bundle has three products, Dogtra Arc black collar which has convertible correction levels, an extra collar which is of orange colour, PetsTEK clicker, and the ARC remote trainer with ¾ mile range. The Dogtra ARC is available in another colour which is CAMO. It also has an LCD screen for display controlled by Rheostat Dial.
In contrast to it Dogtra 1900 is designed mainly for hefty, athletic and well built muscular dogs. This is also waterproof with the IPX9K feature. It has a hands-free dog training device which provides the potential to calibrate the sensitivity of the collar and makes it easy to use.
The collar design for both the products are ergonomically designed so that it is easy for the dog to wear it all day long with comfort.
Dogtra ARC vs. 1900 E-Collar – Corrections
Dogtra ARC has two types of correction. One of the types is a Nick (quick ½-second) and the other correction type is a Constant correction (which is up to 12 seconds). The high quality pager vibration helps transmit clear and timely alerts to dogs which is very beneficial in training. The Dogtra ARC has static stimulation of 127 levels.
On the other hand 1900 E-collar has HPP vibration and is a non-stimulating collar with high performance. The static stimulation level of 1900 is 127 similar to Dogtra ARC. The only difference is that above 60 levels of stimulation, 1900 has a power capacity of 30% and more which supports a higher jump for the dogs.
Dogtra ARC vs. 1900 E-Collar – Usage Limits
Dogtra ARC is expandable for additional pets (dogs) upto two dogs. You can use them for both professional and as well as non-professional dogs. This E-collar is also useful when the dogs have participated in any competitions or in blood sports
Dogtra 1900 can be used only for one dog. You cannot expand the usage beyond that. This is mainly for professional dogs.
Dogtra ARC vs. 1900 E-Collar – Mode
Dogtra ARC allows a constant Nick Correction and Pager Vibration which helps to keep your dog alert and focused.
In Dogtra 1900 also you can opt for the Momentary Nick mode to remit a single pulse of electrical stimulation.In case your dog is still refusing to pay attention, you can select the Constant Stimulation mode. This will help you distribute an uninterrupted stimulation for up to the time limit of 12 seconds.
Dogtra ARC vs. 1900 E-Collar – Reliability
Dogtra is a trustable brand that is serving pet owners for a long time. Both the ARC and 1900 training collar is one of the best options in the market for dogs providing training facilities from soft to well built dogs with high temperament.
The products are friendly and very efficacious thus making it a well grounded item. The collar as well as the remote are made of high quality and durable materials which are comfortable and congenial at the same time. The products are safe to use and don’t hurt the pets at all.
Apart from all these, Dogtra as a brand has superb customer care support, providing information, solution, and help at any [point of time.
Pros and Cons
- Unique Design of the Receiver – Because of its exceptional design the receiver fits comfortably on the dog’s collar without making him uneasy. It also increases the accuracy that the contact points transmit, Alos, because of its discreet design and sleek outlook it is hard for any outsider to spot the collar.
- Adjustable Stimulation Level – The Dogtra ARC put forward a stimulation level ranging from 0-127 levels. It is controlled by Rheostat dial, therefore you can gradually adjust the correction level by increasing or decreasing it based on your requirements.
- LCD Screen – The LCD view makes it very convenient for the trainer to track and view the stimulation levels. Some of the texts that are displayed are – battery life, stimulation levels, etc.
- Absence of tone – Along with non-stimulating vibrations it is preferred to have a warning tone also as an option. There are certain types of dogs which respond and act better with an alarming warning tone.
- Not for diverse types and categories of dogs – This E-collar is best suited for small to medium range of dogs. It would have been better if it was designed for multiple dog sizes and breeds.
- Replace Toggle Switches with inbuilt memory – It is favourable to have a functional memory available instead of toggle switches in the remote transmitters. Toggle switches make it difficult for trainers while they are training more than one dog. They need to always be on a lookout while switching for different dogs. This can also lead to an error of over and under stimulation when immediate reaction is required.
- Range – A range of 3/4-mile is suitable for most of the training circumstances.
- Charging – Splitter Cable and charger are incorporated in the packaging. This will facilitate the charging of each component of the collar at the same time.
- LCD Screen – Blue colour of the LCD screen makes the content easy for reading, also in the dim lights. This helps in keeping a tab in the battery levels. It also tracks the current location thus helping you monitor your pets. A battery life indicator is present on both the transmitter and the receiver which has 3-bars as indicators.
- Electronic Correction – Complete range of electronic correction course of action is present. This involves ‘Constant’ stimulation, ‘Nick stimulation, and non-electronic ‘Vibration Only pager process.
- Type of dogs – This is an apt choice if you are looking forward to training your pets for obedience or training for a sport dog.
- Dog size and weight – Not applicable for dogs that have weight lower than 20 pounds.
- Lack of diversity – This is a medium to high power instruction collar perfect for larger and dogs usually which are more of stubborn breed. It would have been best if it is available for all dog types.
Conclusion

Training collar systems are a good choice to have if you are a dog owner and want to make your dog more obedient and practiced. Both the products of Dogtra 0 ARC and 1900 are good in their own way but based on your dog and requirements you can make the choice. If you have a small dog and up for light training then you can opt for Dogtra ARC.
Whereas if you have a larger breed and want to train your dog more professionally, or if you are a K-9 officer and want a dog in the force which will help you in a more difficult situation, you can opt for Dogtra 1900. One of the cool features of Dogtra 1900 is that it’s hands-free and you can adjust the level of sensitivity. This is very helpful in case of ill-mannered dogs and if your dogs are very stubborn in nature. Cost-wise both the items are very efficient and pocket friendly given their feature and brand value. However Dogtra ARC is slightly cheaper than Dogtra 1900. It is also a bit more sophisticated. So go ahead start planning the training for your dog and get the best e-collar for them suited to your needs!
Leave a Reply